Thursday 22 December 2016

#025 Kinder "Upfall" & Story Of A River, John Muir Award and Millet Prolighter 30 on test.


The weather man said Storm Barbara is approaching and will hit over Christmas. Meanwhile, looking out across Hayfield village this morning, the winter sun lit up the rooftops. A fresh clear blue sky above, pin sharp, saturated colour. Just time to head out into the hills.

My proposal, for the first 'Discovery' level of The John Muir Award, had recently been approved. In a few months time the outcome of this project will be a short film (working title: Kinder - the story of a river). The film will showcase the geology and flora of the river, discuss current conservation issues and highlight my home village of Hayfield as a great base for outdoor enthusiasts to begin their Peak District adventures.

I saddled up my new Millet Prolighter 30 and took Rafa on a preparatory walk along the course of the River Kinder, from Bowland Bridge to just below The Downfall waterfall. We enjoyed a quiet afternoon, gradually ascending, until we reached a point just below the cascade of the Downfall.

Along the way, I took some a selection of photos from which to build a shot list and narrative for the film. I was also luck enough to get to the Downfall on a day with a south westerly wind, which turns it into Kinder 'Upfall'.

The ground was quite broken and the rocks slippy so I decided not to traverse below the waterfall this time. Rafa had been a good boy following my route, but was looking tired. We retraced out steps and meandered home where I had a nice cup of tea and the boy fell fast asleep on his bed.


With over 15 years of service on overseas expeditions and in the UK, my old Berghaus Extem Guide pack is looking a bit frayed. I'm not quite ready to retire the old workhorse, a few stitches here and there will see it right for a while longer. For a while I've been looking at what's new on the market and to have a replacement in reserve just in case the Extrem Guide fails beyond repair.

Working as a Mountain Leader means I am more concerned about longevity than ultra light weight kit. Also, whilst I do generally believe you get what you pay for, I'm not going be shelling out thick wedges of cash either. I like the un-fussy alpine style packs with a single compartment. I never did use the lower zip on the Berghaus or the two compartment divider.

Features I look for are:

  • A couple of attachment points for ice axe, or more frequently walking poles
  • Small compartment in the lid for quick access to snacks and possibles.
  • Reinforced base to stand up to 'sit down, packs off' routine (after all, any fool can be uncomfortable on safari!)
  • Comfortable back design and stable pack when loaded.
After a lot more searching than I had expected to do, I came across the Millet Prolighter 30. I actually saw it first on another walker, while I was guiding clients on Ben Nevis. I thought that it looked good and was a tidy design. A internet trawl and I acquired a red one from Tiso, reduced from £99 to £79.

Today was the first test of my Millet Prolighter 30. Loaded with the usual items of emergency kit, water bottle, my food, Rafa's snacks and his spare coat, the pack felt comfortable and stable. From our fast walk in, along established trails, to following the upper reaches of the River Kinder across rough country and a spot of rock hopping near the Downfall, I was very pleased with its performance. Time shall reveal if it lives up to the apparent durability. But for now, if its good enough for the Chamonix Guides Company, its good enough for me.

Merry Christmas and a peaceful New Year
Stu Westfield

Ranger Expeditions & Ultras

The Montane Spine Race Safety Team & Training Coordinator

Monday 17 October 2016

#024 Spine Race Training Weekend (14-16 Oct 2016)

This weekend, The Spine Team hosted Spine Racers and Challengers for our annual Training Weekend (TW), at the Hebden Hey Scout Centre. The event is a great opportunity for racers to gain skills, knowledge and insights into what it takes to finish The Spine and Spine Challenger. 

For the TW we run a reduced Safety Team sufficient to provide hq, checkpoint, safety ops room and on course safety roles. Its a chance for us to welcome new volunteers as well as catching up with old friends on the team. Its also important that the TW is fulfilling for everyone that supports the Spine and to gain experience in different roles. 

To quote Jon O'Connell, regular Spine Safety Team volunteer:
"The Spine is a great opportunity to work with industry professionals. Where else could you gain this level of knowledge and experience in exchange for a little spare time?"

Friday evening began with speakers sessions. This year we were treated to four entertaining and quality talks from: Andy Mouncey (Cracking The Spine), Pete Wilkie (First Time Spine, 3rd Place Finish) Richard Lendon (Multiple Spine Finisher) & Tom Jones (Spine Racer & Spine Team). 

Each discussed their personal approach to developing a race finishing strategy. All the audience particularly appreciated the speakers sharing their stories of when things did not go to plan and self-less analysis of why this happened. Every session was delivered with great humour accompanied by a lot of laughter too. 

Saturday began with a quick safety briefing from Training Coordinator, Stu Westfield and then a kit check before participant headed out onto the 47 mile Mary Townley Loop (MTL) for a day out on the trail.

For 2016 we added several scenarios designed to get racers thinking about their use of kit, skills, route finding ability and preparedness for The Spine Race and Challenger. Each scenario was at a location where Spine Safety Team were on hand to provide support and guidance to help racers in their approach and solution to the task.

Back at the Hebden Hey Scout Centre, members of the Safety Team worked in rotation to manage the Ops Room; Receiving updates from on-course safety team checkpoints, monitoring racers as they progressed around the MTL. Occasional interventions were made to recover participants from the course who had injuries, or moving participants up the course so they could benefit from a mini-reccie of the Pennine Way approach to Hebden Hey from Stoodley Pike - a section of Spine route which has often caused route finding difficulties.

Race Director, Scott Gilmour cooked up a tasty spaghetti bolognese for participants returning to Hebden Hey. And, once everyone was safely off the course, a few tinnies of beer made an appearance.

The Spine TW concluded on Sunday morning with three speaker sessions: Tom Jones (creative footwear solutions), Matt & Ellie (Spine Film produced by Summit Fever), Dr Fiona Beddoes-Jones (Cognitive fitness for the Spine Race).

The quality and number of speakers this year has been outstanding, thank you all. 
To illustrate this and as a sample of the breadth and depth of shared staff knowledge at the Spine Training events, here is a link to Fiona's presentation:

Also huge thanks to the dedication of The Spine Team out on the 47 mile training loop, implementing our training 'scenarios', sharing knowledge and ensuring racers welfare. Equally the Spine Team members at Hebden Hey were safe hands in the Ops Room. 

Feedback from racers on each of our TWs continues to be very positive, with many comments as to how much the training has helped them focus (or indeed re-focus) their race strategy; the knowledge they have learnt that they were not aware of; what great value the TW is; the camaraderie within the Spine Team and how we welcome and work with racers to help them achieve the best possible outcome. 

Also, a date for your diaries. After thorough planning, the Spine Team announced the first edition of the Summer Spine will be in 2017. This will coincide with the Summer Solstice. (Remember, if the race doesn't have 'Spine' in the title, its not the original and best). Just like the Spine Challenger, the Summer Spine is a superb race in its own right, as well as a progressive stepping stone for racers building up to the winter Spine. 

Our programme of Official Montane Spine Training events continues with Open Group Training at Spine Advanced Skills (4th December 2016), Spine Masterclass & Spine Challenger Masterclass. Plus 1-to-1 training available. See for more details...

For the Summer Spine we will be offering similar group and 1-to-1 training opportunities. To stay in touch with the latest news see Join the Official Spine Group on Facebook and updates on The Montane Spine website. 

Meanwhile sincere thanks from myself, and Race Directors Scott Gilmour & Phil Hayday Brown.  

Stu Westfield 
Montane Spine Race 
Training & Safety Team Coordinator

Wednesday 31 August 2016

#023 Expeditions, Projects & Extinctions

'Anthropocene Extinction', 'Poaching Crisis', 'Marine Destruction'.

A reading of the September 2016 'Extinction Special' edition of Geographical magazine, leaves a sense of dismay at how desperate things have got for many of the living things on our planet. There's nothing new about the message, our most well known and respected naturalists have been broadcasting it for years. David Attenborough's State Of The Planet address at the turn of the millennium made for hard viewing.

As Homo sapiens relentlessly encroaches on the natural world and its inhabitants, the viewer is presented with a choice: leave behind a flourishing planet or a dying one.

"The future of life on earth depends on our ability to take action. Many individuals are doing what they can, but real success can only come if there is a change to our societies and our economics and in our politics. I've been lucky in my lifetime to see some of the greatest spectacles that the natural world has to offer. Surely we have a responsibility to leave for future generations a planet that is healthy, inhabitable by all species".
                                                                                    David Attenborough - in closing.

So what is meant by the Anthropocene (or Holocene) extinction? Without putting shoe shine on it, we are currently living in the middle of a mass extinction event, which is principally down to the proliferation of modern humans. Not since the Cretaceous, 66 million years ago, has the rate of extinction been so high, some estimates have it currently running at tens of thousands of species per year! The Anthropocene epoch covers many thousands of years, but lets look at just a few examples of the iconic mammals and marsupials we have lost forever in the past 150 years: Quagga, Thylacine*, Pyrenean Ibex, Javan Tiger and the Western Black Rhino, in 2011!

(*Based on a novel by Julia Leigh, if ever there was a film dramatising the madness of extinction, The Hunter is that film. The ending...!)

Then add to this the locally extinct mammals, birds, amphibians and collapse of marine ecosystems. It doesn't take a clairvoyant to see that things are set to get much worse:

"If you're an animal bigger than a breadbox and not more than a day, or half day's walk from a road, your days are numbered"
                                                               William Robichaud - Global Wildlife Conservation

Most of my personal wildlife experience has been focused upon sub-saharan Africa, and in particular East Africa. The current poaching crisis occasionally makes the television news, so its safe to say most of us are aware of the problems facing elephant and rhino. But to couch some numbers against this: In March 2016, The Guardian reported that African elephants 'are being killed faster than they are born'. Statistics from Save The Rhino indicate that, in South Africa alone, over 1000 rhino have been poached each year in 2013, 2014 & 2015. This has risen from just thirteen in 2007.

However, fewer people know that since 1900 the African lion population has dropped from one million to just 20,000 by current estimates. Rather than poaching, it seems the cause is down to human encroachment. The area which wild lions are now known to cover has shrunk to just eight percent of their historical range. How could the fact that the king of beasts is in serious trouble have dropped off the media radar?

The reason could be to do with our perception of time. Conservation, by definition, tries to protect what is here today. If encroachment and degradation of habitat happens over a long period of time, several decades or more than a human lifetime (in the case of African lions) then the animal population is managed to fit within its slowly depleting range. In his thought provoking and illuminating book Feral, George Monbiot describes this as 'shifting baseline syndrome' where species are being managed into extinction.

The evocative and sometimes controversial remedy to baseline shift is to reinstate the extent and diversity of habitat by 're-wilding'. Several years ago, before many people had come across the term, I made this the subject for one of my discussions during my Mountain Leader Assessment. I started off with management of chalk grassland to facilitate the re-introductions of the rare Adonis blue butterfly, which had gone locally extinct in some regions. Without exception, the group nodded in approval.

Next I moved onto the white tail sea eagle programme in the Western Isles of Scotland. The group listened to this with even more enthusiasm. Anecdotal proof that people readily engage with iconic species. If these animals are protected and are thriving, it is an indicator that the trophic pyramid of life supporting their existence is diverse and healthy. The reintroduction on beaver was next up. Here there were some questions and curiosity, especially from the paddlers in the group, as to their effect upon river systems.

Lastly, I revealed my trump card. The wolf. I don't think anyone expected it. There was a moment of silence, before the thought of this apex predator, extinct in the UK since the 18th Century, once again roaming the wild. But also bringing much needed balance to an environment suffering from over population of deer (there are more deer alive in the UK now that at any other time and their presence is suppressing growth of young trees). The conversation ignited with interest. Although, there remain many hurdles to overcome before wolf reintroduction becomes a reality.

Of course, it's much easier to sell the concept of re-wilding to outdoor leaders who are already enthusiastic about nature and wilderness. But, there are other people who's livelihood and careers come from the land. Re-wilding will attract resentment and hostility if schemes are railroaded without consideration to other land users.

In August 2016, in an interview with The Sunday Times, bushcraft expert, Ray Mears' thoughts illustrate that there is is still much work to do regarding attitudes to re-wilding.

"Plans to reintroduce lynx and wolves should be put on hold until people learn to live with the predators already in Scotland." 

Recently, (amidst the tawdry and shabby politics) a less publicised result of Brexit is the danger that we may lose much of the European legislation which aimed to protect wildlife and habitats. Also there is uncertainty regarding the continuation of scientific funding which underpins this legislation. Unless this is re-routed, rather than appropriated by government, there could be dark times ahead for conservation projects in the British Isles.

But all the legislation, multitude of NGO's, charity campaigning, 'raising awareness', CITIES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora) blocks on trade in animal products, IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature) Red Lists, is obviously not working well enough. Since I was very young there has there been fundraising efforts to 'save the Amazon rainforest'? What happened to all that money? It should have the whole ecosystem protected by now with local people employed as custodians of it.

But, this is not a blog written to 'raise awareness'. Recently, Observer correspondent Peter Ross eloquently wrote on a unrelated subject:

If there is one thing that we need to stop doing as citizens of social media, it's raising awareness. We have more awareness of what is going in the world right now than at any point in human history thanks not only to the internet, but to the instant connectivity that social media provides. Unfortunately mere awareness of any issue actually does nothing.
So instead of this just being a useless rant, I'm going to make one proposal that has the potential for wide reaching and long term good on a global scale.

I'm not going to pretend that there is one magic answer to the issues facing wildlife and habitat. The answers to conservation issues are multi-faceted. But primarily it all comes down to money, the will of governments and of people to care enough to lobby their leaders to take action. Crime, corruption, poverty, access to education and healthcare are all blockers to making change happen.

Indeed, why should a hard working family in the UK, who are having to rely upon food banks to feed their kids, care about what happens in Africa (or anywhere else for that matter) when they are living in a dystopian country seemingly intent on sending whole sections of society back to Dickensian times. If this seems like a hard sell, then next try convincing the subsistence communities in developing countries.

Conservationists often speak of ensuring wildlife is here for our children and future generations. Talking about tomorrows generations is too abstract, too easy to think of as less immediate. Well here's the wake up, those children and teenagers are already here and they're growing up fast. They are the upcoming entrepreneurs, leaders and influencers of opinion and policy.

On the expeditions I lead, I'm frequently surprised at how disengaged many young people feel about environmental issues. It's as if the last 30 years of blue chip BBC Natural History Unit films and the message they carry hasn't yet made it onto the national curriculum. One complaint I do have about wildlife programmes is that they 'raise awareness' - that phrase again - but rarely go on to suggest what difference the viewer can make (other than simply coughing up money).

If our natural world is going to survive the Anthropocence, isn't it about time to inspire and engage a whole generation in a practical way?

I have been a leader for schools expedition company World Challenge, for six years. During this time I have worked alongside Challegers on some superb community projects: Helping local laborers rebuild the house of a genocide widow in Rwanda has to be the most poignant. On every project I am extremely proud of the Challengers and what they have achieved with just hand tools and a lot of hard graft.

When on World Challenge in Namibia, the trekking phase was in the Gondwana Concession section of Fish River Canyon. The custodian of the base hostel was also a biologist. She had worked with school groups conducting ecological surveys and suggested that school's expedition companies could make a useful contribution to this kind of data gathering. Since then, this topic has arisen regularly in conversations with fellow expedition and outdoor leaders.

The ethos of schools expedition companies can include environmental awareness alongside the experiential development of the participants. There are other companies which focus on selling conservation tourism, but these tend to be the sole focus of the trip. It seems that there remains an untapped resource and opportunity available to schools expeditions to move beyond awareness and into significant action.

Offering conservation projects as a part of the developmental ethos would have a far reaching positive legacy as well as a new business growth opportunity.

The traditional type of expedition projects are already providing subsidy to communities, so why not take this principle and apply it to conservation and ecological assignments. Science and research is data driven. The immediate benefit would be the contribution made by participants to this at grass roots level. The participants would gain training and skills for example in species identification, surveying, sampling, statistics, tracking methods and technology. To ensure that the activity yields useful results, it might include a training phase in advance of the project, possibly even in the home country.

Participants benefit in gaining skills, experience and real world context to their studies, making their portfolio more attractive to higher education applications and employers.
Science and conservation benefits from a subsidised workforce to achieve faster conclusions.
Wildlife benefits from more action in reversing habitat destruction and the rush to extinction.

Careful selection of projects would ensure participants believe and know what they are doing is important and that it will make a real difference. It's an litmus test which is already being applied to community type projects by reputable schools expedition providers. If we look at the schools expedition providers in the UK alone, if just half of the projects shift towards a conservation emphasis, there would be hundreds of expeditions each year with thousands of participants, providing the potential for enormous and far reaching positive change.

It is only by winning hearts and minds of this generation that we will win the battle against the Anthropocene Extinction.


Wednesday 24 August 2016

#022 Cookin' Up East African Style


In July 2016, I led my sixth expedition for World Challenge. With many previous visits on safari and trekking, each time I return to East Africa, in particular Tanzania, feels like coming home. But, the south was to be a new experience. In many ways, I found the pace of life easy going. The trekking and safari operations were low key, but no less professional than their counterparts on the Northern Circuit, Mt Meru and Kilimanjaro.

While on the project phase, the team camped in a quiet and picturesque wood bordering the Udzungwe Mountains National Park and adjacent to the Msosa River. During our stay, Victor, the camp manager arranged for us to participate in a day preparing and tasting East African style food. It was a great experience and very beneficial to the team throughout the expedition, in helping us see what is possible to create with just a few fresh ingredients.

We also tasted the fruit of the Baobab tree. High in antioxidants, essential minerals and vitamin C, baobab fruit is being hailed as a 'new' superfood and now being added to cereal bars and smoothies. Traditional uses include, mixing the fruit powder with water and sugar to produce a sherbet like drink.
However, eaten from the husk, it tastes a little astringent and dry.

On arriving in Dar Es Salaam, at the beginning of our expedition, we had to decide what we would be cooking on. Our basic choices were: meths-trangias, gas burners, charcoal burners and open fire. Naturally, every expedition leader has their own preference. I like the open fire option, but did also acquire two medium size charcoal burners in Morogoro town, just in case we were in locations where firewood was scarce. I didn't want to be cutting trees, if they were scarce around camp sites, for the purpose of cooking, as just a few commercial groups can ruin the very beauty of a place they have come to visit.

Occasionally, whilst waiting for water to boil in the morning for a Africafe coffee, I wished for the instant heat of a gas burner. Prior to the Mt. Rungwe trek, I had met a World Challenge team who had not enjoyed the best of weather on the trail. However, in the following dry sunny days, the pre-cut timber (the trail led through managed cash crop forest) was drier and easy to light with a 'jungle kit' (fire steel, vaseline and cotton wool product). I had brought a parabolic solar fire starter from the UK, but at the times when it was needed (early morning and late afternoon) the sun's rays were either not strong enough or the campsite was under the forest canopy.

I heard one leader had managed to locate a source of meths in Dar Es Salaam. On some expeditions, the search for this has sometimes taken us on a mythical quest, with the red herring of non-combustible cleaning meths (in similar bottles) causing much frustration. However, it appeared that combustible meths in Tanzania can be found in Pharmacies.

I'm not a big fan of trangias when journeying with large groups, they fragment the team and its difficult to have all the ingredients ready at the same time. This said, there was one time in Rwanda where the team were not following their own cooking / washing up rota. So to defuse the tension, we had a tent group 'masterchef' competition. Each tent group were given a fixed amount of money, had to negotiate and agree with each other use of communal items, then cook a substantial dinner with a sample portion for the School Leader and Expedition Leader.


Boil potatoes in salted water
Add vegetables
Add masala spice mix
Add washed rice, then top up with freshly boiled water to cover the mix.

MEAL 2 - BBQ GOAT (Nyama yambusi)
Score goat fillets with knife and put on hot griddle, turning frequently to ensure cooked evenly and thoroughly.

Boil cubed goat meat, drain and fry.
Any unused uncooked meat can be salted and hung, this will keep for a meal the next day.
Fry vegetable mix (cabbage, onions, peppers, carrots, tomatoes)
Add mashed garlic and grated ginger
Put together, add chopped tomatoes, bring to boil and simmer.

A East African staple. Sticky in consistency so can be shaped into a scoop and eaten from a communal stew pot.

MEAL 5 - BEANS (Maharage) with RICE (Wali) or (Ugali)
These beans look like haricot used in baked beans, and taste similar.
They have to be carefully sorted to remove any gritty stones or spoiled beans.
Preparation time is long, as they need to be boiled for 2 hours.

MEAL 6 - CHIPS OMLETTE (Chipsi Mayai)
A Tanzanian favourite. Simply add fried chips to an omlette mix, as one would with a Spanish omlette. Add masala spices or a little chilli sauce to zip up the flavour as desired.

Cheap as chips! Often seen cooked at roadside cafes. Best eaten fresh, usually with stew, but World Challenge groups spread jam for a quick and easy snack.

This essential item of kit should never be too far away from the Expedition Leader.
Almost as good as freshly ground, this brew is highly regarded and provides a useful meal replacement when Challengers have resorted to cooking up the dreaded Beanfeast.

Domestic roles in Tanzania are still very much divided along traditional lines in subsistence communities. What our experience of East African cooking showed, especially when putting it all into practice, was the length of time taken to prepare, cook and serve a meal. For a proper dinner, with staple, vegetables and meat, we rarely achieved a time faster than two hours from the point where we created a flame. Without the luxury of running hot water, washing up was another protracted process. Thank goodness the team had a rota, as this task was among the least popular. 

One challenger made a insightful comment regarding life in the village. How when one meal had barely finished, it was time to start preparing for the next. Yet, women had to fit in time to look after the little ones, do washing and work in the fields. The challengers' return to the UK was, almost without exception, accompanied by a fresh appreciation of home luxuries. Indeed, some had begun to question how much 'stuff' they actually needed.

Furahiya chakula chako!
(Enjoy your meal)

Monday 15 August 2016

#021 A Quantum Of Solace

Expedition Leader, Stu Westfield, reflects upon time journeying along the Tanzania to Zambia highway.


A low bank of grey cloud obscured the horizon. I had hoped to watch the sunrise as I had before, the fiery ball casting hues of magenta, pink and orange before the mid-morning heat. It didn't matter. The tide was in, covering the firm flat sand on which I had enjoyed fast interval training last time I was here. Above the watermark was soft powdery white sand. Not ideal, but it didn't matter.

Because Kipepeo is a long stretch of beach that speaks to me every time I see it and it begs me to run. Every morning in the early light, Tanzanians stride out, with running legs chopping through the soft silica in an easy, effortless style. The air was charged with an infectious warmth, focusing the mind with clarity and building expectation in my limbs. But after a month on multi-phase expedition, my muscles and tendons felt tight. Trekking, community project work and safari had been interspersed with several long journeys on the Tanzam highway whilst confined to a small seat with little leg room on coaster buses.

I stretched, not too deeply at first, then set off. Too fast, I slowed down, finding a more comfortable cadence. Gradually, as movement became more fluid, I dialed into the sweet zone. There was peace and stillness, no rush of wind in my ears, just the swoosh of the Indian Ocean as each ebb and flow gently broke and scooted up to the high tide mark.

There is a saying in Africa: In the morning, the lion runs for its prey and every morning the gazelle must run faster to stay alive. So, no matter who you are, in Africa, when the sun comes up, you'd better be running.

Two Tanzanian lads just overtook me.

East Africa has been food for my soul since my first visit over 12 years ago. But, it has been a far from easy decade. The injustice of bad things happening to good people with alarming regularity has sharpened the mind somewhat. It was a major influence, among others which were rapidly stacking up at the time, in a decision to abandon the gravy train. To refuse to be a slave to a system of false hopes and empty promises. To get back to a life focused upon the enjoyment of experiences.

This was my last day in-country and for the past couple I had been fending off a melancholic sadness at the prospect, as if parting from an old friend. I ran faster, like the antelope. It had been a good month, indeed it was a month filled with firsts; crossing the Great Ruaha River in a dug-out canoe, trekking in the Udzungwa Mountains, visiting Mikumi National Park and leading my group to summit Mount Rungwe. We had traveled from Dar es Salaam in the east all the way to Mbeya in the west and back again, crossing almost the whole width of Tanzania.

At a roadside restaurant, we had met a Belgian couple cycle touring from Dar to Malawi. I recognised them as our coaster bus had passed them the previous day. As they refueled with fresh oranges and grilled meat from the braai, we talked bikes, gears and kit, like cyclists tend to do. They planned to go all the way to Lake Malawi before returning to Dar on the under-utlised and chronically under-funded Tazara narrow gauge line. Virtually all freight and fuel is transported by lorry along the Tanzam highway to west Tanzania. With a little foresight and investment, it wasn't a huge leap of imagination to realise how much could be carried by train.

In the company of Tanzanians, I learnt from Felix our Sisi-Kwa-Sisi trekking guide, one should refer to Lake Malawi as Lake Nyassa. With treaties established under colonial rule, tensions had been bubbling away since independence. Essentially, Felix explained, Malawi has laid claim to the whole of the lake, whilst Tanzania postulates that the border runs along the centre of the lake. The thus far unexploited potential reserves of oil and gas under the lake bed is the cause of frequently raised tensions between the two countries. Locals know when things are kicking off, as vintage military jets fly overhead, rattling the sabre.

Felix changed the subject of conversation. "So tell me about Brexit" he asked.
My head sank in mock despair. "I've come half way around the world and still cannot escape Brexit!".
He laughed, but pursued me further. "What I do know is that politicians have made an awful mess of it and that, in or out, there are a lot of people who feel let down by the whole thing"
"Its the same everywhere" he replied with sage.
"There's got to be a better way" I thought.

Later in the trek, we were joined by local guide Mr. Chaula, who's opening gambit whilst sat around the campfire one evening was:
"So tell me about Brexit?"

River Valley Camp, just outside Iringa, provided an oasis of calm in which to break our journey after a long day on the road. I poured myself a black coffee and sat down on the reception veranda. The veranda was a place vibrant with activity where expedition leaders gathered to oversee final safari and trekking arrangements with the effervescent, Amanda, who put in long hours to ensure each team was taken care of. When the business of the day was done, it became a place where leaders could swap stories, shoot the breeze and talk until the early hours of the morning, all with a never ending cup of Africafe. These were good times.

It was also here that I got talking with an overland biker who had set out from the UK to motor around the continent. Having crossed from Algeciras bay to Morocco he had already rode down the west coast, negotiating the fee for loading his bike on the Congo River, Kinshasa ferry river crossing, down from a ludicrous $200 to $10 over a period of several hours. We shook our heads at the Democratic Republic Of Congo oxymoron.

In the conversation, I forgot to note this intrepid adventurer's name, but I saw him the next morning, preparing for the off. He happily posed beside his Yamaha machine of which he was very proud. "Its not new technology, but it will cope with dodgy fuel, you can get parts almost anywhere and its never failed to start". He patted the fuel tank with paternal appreciation. I wished him the best and wandered over to the restaurant for breakfast.

           "Life moves pretty fast. If you don't stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it" 
                                                                                                                             - Ferris Bueller

I clicked the shutter release and inwardly laughed as the words from Ferris Bueller's Day Off sprang to mind. The rock pools between the Inner and Outer Sinda islands were full of life. More used to shooting (with a camera!) big game, I had gained my marine safari eyes the day previously whilst ambling through the mangroves and coral shelf at the north end of Kipepeo beach. Louise, one our team School Leaders, and myself were accompanied by fellow Expedition Leader, Rachael, who's zoology expertise gave us a guided tour of this fascinating environment. We found sand dollars, spotted hermit crabs and many other species. Then the moment the tide turned and new water flowed into the pools, hundreds of spider star fish emerged from their crevices, tentacles waving as if seeking a meal. It was an event that occurred every high tide, easily missed, but once seen provided a fascinating enjoyment.

My thoughts returned to the present. I finished my run with a satisfying sprint along the length of the beach. The sun was now a few more inches above the horizon. I walked back up to the beach bar, where the staff had just begun to prepare for breakfast by setting out the coffee and hot water urn. I fixed myself a cup of Africafe, it had become the drink of choice for this trip. I guess, just like many expedition leaders, I am hard-wired to the stuff.  It's a kick start in the morning, an appetite suppressant when food is hard to come by and inevitably its the wide awake club social vice in the evening. At the same bar, in a moment of random serendipity I heard my new cool song...Black Coffee by Everlast.

Every expedition isn't just about the things done and places seen. Its about the people you meet, the friends you make and share time with along the way. It's listening to the story of the person next to you which enriches the experience. Its the camaraderie. It's shooting the breeze around the camp fire, sipping black coffee with fellow expedition leaders and re-telling past adventures late into the night.

It is a quantum of solace.

Monday 25 January 2016

#020 The 2016 Spine Safety Team

The 2016 Spine Race showed just how far the event has come in the past five years, with a combination of racing dramas, challenging winter conditions and impressive personal stories of endurance making it a vintage year, maybe even the best ever Spine yet.

The Spine Safety Team has also developed in many respects. For the first Spine, we had about the same small number of staff as racers which started at Edale and the deployments were decided in the moment. As the numbers of starters grew, so did the safety team and also the level of advance planning needed for the team to be as efficient and effective as possible. We now begin refining the deployment plan and putting together Safety Teams at least three months before the race itself.

It is testament to the work and contribution by all of the Spine Safety Team and Race Organisation that other races are looking at our methods and procedures with interest. Specifically, how we can run an event like this in winter with all the variations that can throw at us and not be constantly calling on Mountain Rescue.

Regular Spine Challenger competitors, Tim Vriendt and Stef Schuermans, have organised their own new event, The Legends, held in the Belgium Ardennes, March 2016. For this they have brought in expertise from The Spine Safety Team.


The leaders at the front were nip and tuck right up to the final day, until Eoin Keith stole a march on pursuers Pavel Paloncy and Eugene Rosello Sole. Eoin had made the bold statement that his 2015 finish was simply a reccie in preparation for winning in 2016. He appeared unstoppable in his quest, setting the bar to a new high by taking a huge chunk off Pavel’s course record.

The Challenger too brought many new stories and new faces. There has been a succession of fast performances in this 108 mile dash. Making it highly competitive and arguably now as difficult to win as the full Spine. 

Fresh from their work dealing with the terrible flooding north of Manchester just before the event, we welcomed members of local Mountain Rescue Teams racing a special version of the Challenger. Thankfully for local communities, the water levels had reduced, although the effects are bound to be felt for months.

But, to paraphrase seasoned Spiner, Richard Lendon: “The Spine is more than just touching a stone wall at The Border Inn, Kirk Yetholm (or opening those double doors at The Market House in Hawes). It’s about the experience, the camaraderie and being out there on the trail.”

It’s what I struggled to adequately articulate in the interview with Summit Fever in the 2015 Spine movie, leaving the viewer with the cheesy, if not now legendary, Spine chest thump. Thank you to all the folks that joined in the chest thump salute during Spine week, you made it real!


Race Directors Scott & Phil, had a clear vision for the race organisation with specialist teams, each working autonomously, but sharing information and resources when required to ensure the best possible response and outcome for racers and race volunteers alike. 

At times of high demand, a new on-line incident recording system enabling fast dissemination of information. Each incident remained open and was monitored until the action was closed.


This year’s safety team was based on the model I developed for the 2015 Spine. I have already written in previous blogs about how the horrendous storms in 2015 played havoc with our best laid plans. However, there were still very worthwhile lessons to take forwards.

The first was Safety Team structure. New for 2016, was two teams of Coordinators (Darren Hunt & Jayme Morgan + Stuart Smith & Lindley Chambers) on an alternating 12 hour shift. The shifts ran from midnight to midday, then from midday to midnight. Coordination can be extremely intensive and unrelenting so the aim here was that each pair had a decent opportunity to rest as well as to get out of the Ops Room and see some daylight during the week. In addition to the shift teams, coordinator Paul Gale took care of course safety reccies and supervising CP5.5, Byrness.

The collective skills set and experience of this year’s coordinator team is worthy of note: Mountain & expedition leaders, MRT, event organisation, military service, civilian blue light emergency service, aerospace safety investigation and highly regulated nuclear industry.

This year we especially focussed on communications. Not so much the method of communication, i.e predominantly mobile phone and occasionally sat phones, but rather the way we use them. With extensive experience of the Pennine Way, we now have much better knowledge of mobile black spots, meaning that the SST’s on the ground could be deployed far more effectively.

With Teams using various mobile networks, dual chip phones or Manx sim, if there was a signal available, most of the time someone could connect to it. The preferred method of routine coms was by text, which is succinct and much easier transmitted than voice call. It also freed up ops room phones for incoming priority calls.

In addition to racers having trackers for racers, we also made more use of trackers for SSTs and Medics. On several occasions they proved invaluable in our ability to direct SSTs to racers:
·         For  routine welfare checks
·         To assist in bringing a racer back on track after deviating off route towards a major hazard.
·         To locate racers in difficulty
·         To locate a member of the public (more on this later)

For the fourth consecutive year, medical matters were in the care of Exile Medics, headed by Brett Roccos. We worked closely with Brett and his excellent team, to support competitors. There are many racers who were able to progress a lot further due the assistance of the Exiles doctors.


Like many Ultra Races, The Spine could not exist without volunteers. As SST Coordinator, in addition to race safety, my aim is that our volunteers have the best possible experience during their time with us. The fact that several return year after year, hopefully proves that we are doing it right more often than not. It is often said that working on The Spine can be as hard as racing, but I have heard on many occasions that it is equally as enjoyable.

Many potential Spiners and Challengers use their time on the SST as fact finding for their own future race plans. I’m very much in support of this, Volunteering on a SST provides opportunities for selective course research, route finding, potential conditions underfoot and local resources such as shops and pubs. As well as seeing the effects of race attrition, SSTs can gauge how their endurance capabilities, navigation, hill and expeditions skills compare with the finishers.

The plan for SSTs worked very well this year and our teams were much better rested in between deployments. Throughout the SST there is a diverse range of experience, from Ultra Racers, Mountain Rescue, Emergency & Military Services, Mountain & Expedition Leaders. This is only part of the story, in addition to their professionalism, every member of the SST brought humour and camaraderie which contributes to the Spine ‘race family’ atmosphere.

To all Spine Race volunteers, I offer my sincere thanks for your commitment to the success of the 2016 race. And I look forward to seeing you again, either in the Safety Team, as a Spine Racer, or simply on the hills and trails.


This year the weather was, relatively, kinder to us than 2015. Thankfully there was no repeat of successive gale force weather fronts, preventing movement of racers and the Spine Safety Team. That said, the conditions were far from easy. As if dialled up to order, mild temperatures yielded to Baltic cold, perhaps catching some racers off their guard. 

Snow soon added to the mix, giving a positive Arctic flavour to Malham, Pen-Y-Ghent and the approaches to Hawes.

Safety teams were mostly all in position according to the deployment plan when the snow fell. From these locations of most usefulness and with Exile medics distributed along the race split, the team remained effective. Throughout the week we continued to work around traffic disruption, the whole Spine Team minimising road trips during the night on re-frozen surfaces.

With the leading elites staying a step head, the snow mostly affected the peloton and lanterns rouge. Based on a course reccie, the safety team implemented a diversion, of equal distance, around the Cauldron Snout outflow. Thus, removing the potentially hazardous river edge traverse and frozen scramble up to the dam.

Further snow and drifts on Crossfell meant racers at the rear of the field were grouped together for safety. John Bamber and Paul Shorrock enjoyed a busier than usual stay at Gregs Hut this year, with a number of forays out onto the trail for welfare checks on slower racers. Exile Medics also made the prudent decision to station one of their Doctors at the hut.


The tough conditions underfoot, sudden drop in temperature and fatigue all took their toll on racers. The pace of many began to slow, at times to as little as 1km an hour. At the same time racers completing the Cheviot reported their exhausting efforts breaking trail and post holing, through deep drifts (which was corroborated by watching their trackers).

With the significant reduction in pace of mid-field racers, there was a growing concern among the collective Race Organisation - RDs, SST, HQ, Exile Medics – that:
i)          The Lanterns Rouge could not possibly finish the event in time
ii)         There was a high potential for multiple hypothermia/exhaustion casualties whilst on the remote Cheviots.

In this knowledge, to allow this situation to occur would have shown a reckless disregard for welfare of both racers and the Safety Teams up on the hill. Hence the Byrness cut off had to be brought forward, a decision not taken lightly. This decision was borne out by the fact that the last racer to arrive at Kirk Yetholm did so just 28 minutes prior to the 7 day race time limit.

Most of the racers who finished carried with them stories of epic conditions up on high ground. As it was, our SST’s up at Refuge 1-Lamb Hill and Refuge 2-Auchope had a busy night.

Hut 1 was manned for the duration by experienced Spiner & mountaineer, Mark Caldwell. He was joined by Al Pepper who had completed the Challenger earlier in the week. They helped ensure that racers were safe to continue the Cheviot traverse.

Racers were grouped together in at least pairs (many did this automatically) so that they could share work breaking trail, navigating and also looking out for each other. Past years has shown this buddy system to be very worthwhile.

Our strategy for Hut 2 was to deploy a succession of Teams who would then remotely shadow a group of racers on their final descent into Kirk Yetholm. Coordinator, Darren Hunt, was able to drop off several teams at the College Valley road head, enabling them to reach Hut 2 much more quickly than the standard Halterburn walk in. At one point we had five safety teams on the hill.

With space at a premium in Hut 2, racers who were fit to continue were encouraged to eat, drink and then push onwards to the finish. This was a fine balance, but worked well thanks to Exile medics doctor in-situ and the can-do efforts of the SSTs.

Next year there may not be snow on the ground. With thanks to all SSTs who have provided feedback, we will have to look at improving the water carry up to the Huts. Given the conditions, we took the decision to carry up some extra rations packs to Huts 1 and 2. Whilst I’m sure this was universally appreciated by competitors, we have to be careful that there is not a future expectation of noodles, rat packs or hot drinks service at hut and bothy locations. The main reason, is that SSTs may not actually be in there, but deployed out on the course.


Many of you may have read reports in main-stream media that two Spine racers were rescued by Borders Search And Rescue from the area around Auchope Hut on the final night of the event. Not to let the facts get in the way of a good story, the headlines were incorrect on many levels. With thanks to assistance from Jon O’Connell’s (SST1) father and his media connections, the BBC quickly corrected their copy.

In summary the actual events are thus: A member of the public independently walking the Pennine Way was seen by Spine Racers on the Chevoit ridge. Concerned for his welfare they called Spine Safety Ops, who then tasked an SST to assist. The member of the public was walked to Hut 2 where he was assessed by an Exile Medic and efforts were made to rewarm. After a couple of hours and still concerned for the person’s well- being, BSAR were called, who responded on foot and also brought in SAR Helicopter. On reaching the Hut, the member of the public was deemed fit enough to walk off the hill accompanied by the BSAR team.

As this was happening, a fatigued Spiner being closely escorted off the hill by one of our SSTs needed a little extra help. Instead of us sending up another SST, BSAR who were already in the immediate area offered assistance, for which The Spine is extremely grateful.


The Spine is billed as a self-sufficient and most brutal race in Britain. There has been much commentary on social media that, with the introduction of CP1.5 Malham and CP5.5 Byrness, The Spine is now easier. I think this year proves that the event is still as tough as it ever was. What I would say is that there is a difference in the safety systems we have put in place as a duty of care to our competitors and staff.

However, the Race Organisation is mindful that the self-sufficient ethos is not ‘chipped away’ turning a great race into a beige race. Hence, the Spine will remain in its current mid-winter slot, compulsory kit items such as stoves and rations should be carried at all times and there are definitely no pacers.


·         Make sure navigation skills are well practiced in the conditions which they are to be used. i.e. on a cold wet trail and in the dark.

·         Look at the weather reports and adjust strategy / kit / clothing accordingly.   Eg would snowshoes have been a useful addition this year?

·         Be aware of own pacing. The strategy of just meeting cut offs does not work for many competitors who try it, with a lot DNFs this year due to too much time on the feet, insufficient rest and sleep deprivation - even before the revised cut off at CP5.5 is taken into account. The suggestion here is to build some contingency into a race finishing strategy. Start with aiming for a 6 ½ day completion, which leaves 12 hours for weather events or indeed a little extra rest in the final stages.

·         Come to the Official Spine Training Weekend in autumn for an enjoyable 2 days totally focussed on the top tips, shared experience and essential skills needed to finish The Spine.

·         Start your build up to the 2017 Spine now.

·         Join our ‘Complete Spine Racer’ course offered by Official Spine Training Provider, Ranger Expeditions / Stu Westfield – Spine Safety Team & Training Coordinator. Within an informal and friendly atmosphere (for small groups and 1-to-1) we guide you through kit, strategies and share insights from the 5 years of the Spine Race to help you achieve your Challenger or Spine finish. We also spend plenty of time in Pennine Way country developing your route finding navigation skills.

Stu Westfield
Spine Safety Team Coordinator
Legends Safety Team Coordinator
Ranger Ultras Safety Team Coordinator